| Season Year | Play No. | Month Year | Title | Author | Director |
| 1. 1947-48 | 1 | Apr 1948 | Yes and No | Kenneth Horne | |
| 2. 1948-49 | 2 | Feb 1949 | Winter Sunshine | G A Thomas | |
| 3. 1949-50 | 3 | Nov 1949 | Square Pegs | Unknown | |
| 4. 1950-51 | 4 | Nov 1950 | First Fiddle | Unknown | |
| 5. 1951-52 | 5 | Nov 1951 | Happiest Days of Your Life | John Dighton | |
| 6. 1952-53 | 6 | Nov 1952 | Wishing Well | E Eynon Evans | |
| 7. 1953-54 | 7 | Nov 1953 | Happy Prisoner | John McNair | |
| 8. 1954-55 | 8 | Nov 1954 | Murder at the Vicarage | Agatha Christie | |
| 9. 1955-56 | 9 | Nov 1955 | Half A Loaf | Frederick Lonsdale | |
| 10. 1956-57 | 10 | Nov 1956 | Man In Grey | Eleanor Smith | |
| 11 | May 1957 | Down Came A Blackbird | Peter Blackmore | ||
| 11. 1957-58 | 12 | Sep 1957 | Love’s A Luxury | Hoile/Paxton | |
| 13 | Apr 1958 | Middle Watch | Stephen King-Hall | ||
| 12. 1958-59 | 14 | Sep 1958 | Spider’s Web | Agatha Christie | |
| 15 | Apr 1959 | Tons of Money | Alan Ayckbourn | ||
| 13. 1959-60 | 16 | Sep 1959 | Browning Version | Terence Rattigan | |
| 14. 1960-61 | 17 | Nov 1960 | Bonaventure | Charlotte Hastings | |
| 18 | May 1961 | Not in the Book | Arthur Watkyn | ||
| 15. 1961-62 | 19 | Dec 1961 | Breath of Spring | Peter Coke | |
| 20 | May 1962 | Summer in December | James Liggatt | ||
| 16. 1962-63 | 21 | Oct 1962 | When We Are Married | J B Priestley | |
| 22 | May 1963 | Friends and Neighbours | Austin Steele | ||
| 17. 1963-64 | 23 | Nov 1963 | Murder Out Of Tune | Falkland L Cary | |
| 24 | Jan 1964 | Pools Paradise | Philip King | ||
| 25 | Apr 1964 | Intent To Murder | Leslie Sands | ||
| 18. 1964-65 | 26 | Oct 1964 | Hot and Cold in All Rooms | Max Reitmann | |
| 27 | Feb 1965 | Goodnight Mrs Puffin | Arthur Lovegrove | ||
| 28 | Apr 1965 | Cat on the Fiddle | John Dole | ||
| 19. 1965-66 | 29 | Nov 1965 | Time Murderer Please | Charles Dyer | |
| 30 | Apr 1966 | My Flesh, My Blood | Bill Naughton | ||
| 20. 1966-67 | 31 | Oct 1966 | Two Dozen Red Roses | Kenneth Horne | |
| 32 | Apr 1967 | A Public Mischief | Kenneth Horne | ||
| 21. 1967-68 | 33 | Nov 1967 | Johnny Belinda | Elmer Harris | |
| 34 | Apr 1968 | Person Unknown | Chase/Clayton | ||
| 22. 1968-69 | 35 | Nov 1968 | Diplomatic Baggage | John Chapman | |
| 36 | Mar 1969 | Spark in Judea | RF Delderfield | ||
| 37 | Apr 1969 | The Noble Spaniard | W Somerset Maugham | ||
| 23. 1969-70 | 38 | Oct 1969 | It Won’t Be A Stylish Marriage | AP Dearsley | |
| 39 | Feb 1970 | I’ll Get My Man | Philip King | ||
| 24. 1970-71 | 40 | Nov 1970 | The Admirable Crichton | JM Barrie | |
| 41 | Mar 1971 | A Boston Story | Ronald Gow | ||
| 25. 1971-72 | 42 | Oct 1971 | Eh? | Henry Livings | |
| 43 | Feb 1972 | Birthday Honours | Paul Jones | ||
| 26. 1972-73 | 44 | Oct 1972 | Hindle Wakes | Stanley Houghton | |
| 45 | Apr 1973 | Arms and the Man | George Bernard Shaw | ||
| 27. 1973-74 | 46 | Oct 1973 | Plaza Suite | Neil Simon | |
| 47 | Feb 1974 | Lady Precious Stream | SI Hsuing | ||
| 28. 1974-75 | 48 | Nov 1974 | Collapse of Stout Party | Trevor Peacock | |
| 49 | Dec 1974 | Augustus Does His Bit | George Bernard Shaw | ||
| 50 | Apr 1975 | Time and Time Again | Alan Ayckbourn | ||
| 29. 1975-76 | 51 | Oct 1975 | The Anniversary | Bill Macilwraith | |
| 52 | Feb 1976 | Home and Beauty | W Somerset Maugham | ||
| 30. 1976-77 | 53 | Sep 1976 | Black Chiffon | Lesley Storm | |
| 54 | Mar 1977 | Pillar to Post | John Waterhouse | ||
| 31. 1977-78 | 55 | Oct 1977 | Wedding of the Year | Norman Robbins | |
| 56 | Feb 1978 | Out of the Crocodile | Giles Cooper | ||
| 57 | Apr 1978 | The Bespoke Overcoat | Wolf Mankowitz | ||
| 32. 1978-79 | 58 | Nov 1978 | Who Killed Santa Claus | Terence Feely | |
| 59 | Apr 1979 | Two and Two Make Sex | Harris/Darbon | ||
| 33. 1979-80 | 60 | Oct 1979 | An Inspector Calls | JB Priestley | |
| 61 | Feb 1980 | Table Manners | Alan Ayckbourn | ||
| 34. 1980-81 | 62 | Nov 1980 | Arsenic and Old Lace | Joseph Kesselring | |
| 63 | Apr 1981 | Bedroom Farce | Alan Ayckbourn | ||
| 35. 1981-82 | 64 | Oct 1981 | Outside Edge | Richard Harris | |
| 65 | Feb 1982 | Blithe Spirit | Noel Coward | ||
| 36. 1982-83 | 66 | Oct 1982 | Night Watch | David Campton | |
| 67 | Apr 1983 | Round and Round the Garden | Alan Ayckbourn | ||
| 37. 1983-84 | 68 | Oct 1983 | Lord Arthur Savile’s Crime | Wilde/Cox | |
| 69 | Feb 1984 | The Prisoner of Second Avenue | Neil Simon | ||
| 38. 1984-85 | 70 | Oct 1984 | Billy Liar | Waterhouse/Hall | |
| 71 | Nov 1984 | Just Between Ourselves | Alan Ayckbourn | ||
| 72 | Feb 1985 | A Coat of Varnish | Ronald Millar | ||
| 73 | May 1985 | Children’s Day | Waterhouse/Hall | ||
| 39. 1985-86 | 74 | Oct 1985 | Stage Struck | Simon Gray | |
| 75 | Feb 1986 | Season’s Greetings | Alan Ayckbourn | ||
| 76 | Apr 1986 | Harvey | Mary Chase | ||
| 40. 1986-87 | 77 | Oct 1986 | Absurd Person Singular | Alan Ayckbourn | |
| 78 | Feb 1987 | The Right Honourable Gentleman | M Bradley-Dyne | ||
| 79 | Apr 1987 | On Golden Pond | Ernest Thompson | ||
| 41. 1987-88 | 80 | Oct 1987 | Come On Jeeves! | Wodehouse/Bolton | |
| 81 | Feb 1988 | The Skin Game | John Galsworthy | ||
| 82 | Apr 1988 | View From The Bridge | Arthur Miller | ||
| 42. 1988-89 | 83 | Oct 1988 | Crimes of the Heart | Beth Henley | |
| 84 | Feb 1989 | A Chorus of Disapproval | Alan Ayckbourn | ||
| 85 | Apr 1989 | The Poker Session | Hugh Leonard | ||
| 43. 1989-90 | 86 | Oct 1989 | Farndale Ave Murder Mystery | McGillivray/Zerlin | |
| 87 | Feb 1990 | An Enemy of the People | Ibsen/Miller | ||
| 88 | Apr 1990 | Corpse! | Gerald Moon | ||
| 44. 1990-91 | 89 | Oct 1990 | Curtains | Stephen Bill | |
| 90 | Feb 1991 | Pygmalion | George Bernard Shaw | ||
| 91 | Apr 1991 | The March On Russia | David Storey | ||
| 45. 1991-92 | 92 | Oct 1991 | Steel Magnolias | Robert Harling | |
| 93 | Feb 1992 | The Picture of Dorian Grey | Wilde/Anderson | ||
| 94 | Apr 1992 | Ten Times Table | Alan Ayckbourn | ||
| 46. 1992-93 | 95 | Oct 1992 | Relatively Speaking | Alan Ayckbourn | |
| 96 | Feb 1993 | The Light of Heart | Emlyn Williams | ||
| 97 | Apr 1993 | Oh Clarence! | John Chapman | ||
| 47. 1993-94 | 98 | Oct 1993 | Separate Tables | Terence Rattigan | |
| 99 | Feb 1994 | Habeas Corpus | Alan Bennett | ||
| 100 | Apr 1994 | Entertaining Mr Sloane | Joe Orton | ||
| 48. 1994-95 | 101 | Oct 1994 | House Guest | Francis Durbridge | |
| 102 | Feb 1995 | A Night On The Tiles | Frank Vickery | ||
| 103 | Apr 1995 | Time and Time Again | Alan Ayckbourn | ||
| 49. 1995-96 | 104 | Oct 1995 | Bazaar and Rummage | Sue Townsend | |
| 105 | Feb 1996 | Run For Your Wife | Ray Cooney | ||
| 106 | Apr 1996 | Beyond Reasonable Doubt | Jeffrey Archer | ||
| 50. 1996-97 | 107 | Oct 1996 | When We Are Married | JB Priestley | |
| 108 | Feb 1997 | Loot | Joe Orton | ||
| 109 | Apr 1997 | Natural Causes | Eric Chappell | ||
| 51. 1997-98 | 110 | Oct 1997 | Cat’s Cradle Cradle | Leslie Sands | |
| 111 | Feb 1998 | Straight and Narrow | Jimmie Chinn | ||
| 112 | Apr 1998 | Haunted | Eric Chappell | ||
| 52. 1998-99 | 113 | Oct 1998 | Sylvia’s Wedding | Jimmie Chinn | |
| 114 | Feb 1999 | Bedroom Farce | Alan Ayckbourn | ||
| 115 | Apr 1999 | Theft | Eric Chappell | ||
| 53. 1999-2000 | 116 | Oct 1999 | The Killing of Sister George | Frank Marcus | |
| 117 | Feb 2000 | Who Killed Santa Claus | Terence Feely | ||
| 118 | Apr 2000 | The Odd Couple (Female Version) | Neil Simon | ||
| 54. 2000-01 | 119 | Oct 2000 | Murder For The Asking | Derek Benfield | |
| 120 | Feb 2001 | The Deep Blue Sea | Terence Rattigan | ||
| 121 | Apr 2001 | Lord Arthur Savile’s Crime | Wilde/Cox | ||
| 55. 2001-02 | 122 | Oct 2001 | Day of Reckoning | Pam Valentine | |
| 123 | Feb 2002 | It Runs In The Family | Ray Cooney | ||
| 124 | Apr 2002 | Triple Chinn | Jimmie Chinn | ||
| 56. 2002-03 | 125 | Oct 2002 | Clerical Errors | Georgina Reid | |
| 126 | Feb 2003 | Heatstroke | Eric Chappell | ||
| 127 | Apr 2003 | Relative Values | Noel Coward | ||
| 128 | June 2003 | Respecting Your Piers | Peter Quilter | ||
| 57. 2003-04 | 129 | Oct 2003 | Pack Of Lies | Hugh Whitemore | |
| 130 | Feb 2004 | Fly In The Ointment | Derek Benfield | ||
| 131 | Apr 2004 | Plaza Suite | Neil Simon | ||
| 132 | Jun 2004 | Elsie and Norm’s Macbeth | JC Wood | ||
| 58. 2004-05 | 133 | Oct 2004 | The Prisoner of Second Avenue | Neil Simon | |
| 134 | Feb 2005 | Fiddlers Three | Eric Chappell | ||
| 135 | Apr 2005 | Dead Guilty | Richard Harris | ||
| 136 | Jun 2005 | Barefoot In The Park | Neil Simon | ||
| 137 | Jul 2005 | A Midsummer Night’s Dream | William Shakespeare | ||
| 59. 2005-06 | 138 | Oct 2005 | Blood Money | The Heather Brothers | |
| 139 | Feb 2006 | The Trouble With Old Lovers | Angela Huth | ||
| 140 | Apr 2006 | Blithe Spirit | Noel Coward | ||
| 141 | Jun 2006 | Steel Magnolias | Robert Harling | ||
| 142 | Jul 2006 | Twelfth Night | William Shakespeare | ||
| 60. 2006-07 | 143 | Oct 2006 | Journey’s End | RC Sherrif | |
| 144 | Feb 2007 | Our Town | Thornton Wilder | ||
| 145 | Apr 2007 | Abigail’s Party | Mike Leigh | ||
| 146 | Jun 2007 | Summer End | Eric Chappell | ||
| 61. 2007-08 | 147 | Oct 2007 | Dangerous Liaisons | Christopher Hamptons | |
| 148 | Feb 2008 | Moon Over Buffalo | Ken Ludwig | ||
| 149 | Apr 2008 | A Passionate Woman | Kay Mellor | ||
| 150 | Jun 2008 | Oysters and Snails | Philip Holyman | Vida Green | |
| 62. 2008-09 | 151 | Oct 2008 | Fly Me To The Moon | John Godber | Val Best |
| 152 | Feb 2009 | The Secret Diary of Adrian Mole Aged 13 3/4 | Sue Townsend | Chas Burnell | |
| 153 | Apr 2009 | Treehouses | Elizabeth Kuti | Jennifer Smith | |
| 154 | Jun 2009 | The Shakespeare Review | Luscombe/McKee | Stephen Ralph | |
| 63. 2009-10 | 155 | Oct 2009 | Educating Rita | Willy Russell | Mike Penn |
| 156 | Feb 2010 | London Suite | Neil Simon | ||
| 157 | Apr 2010 | Flatspin | Alan Ayckbourn | ||
| 158 | Jun 2010 | Rope | Patrick Hamilton | Stephen Ralph | |
| 64. 2010-11 | 159 | Oct 2010 | Spring & Port Wine | Bill Naughton | Anne Chamberlain |
| 160 | Feb 2011 | Something’s Burning | Eric Chappell | Chris Pomlett | |
| 161 | Apr 2011 | The History Boys | Alan Bennett | Jennifer Smith | |
| 162 | Jun 2011 | Duets | Peter Quilter | Dawn Vigurs | |
| 65. 2011-12 | 163 | Oct 2011 | The Graduate | Terry Johnson | Stephen Ralph |
| 164 | Feb 2012 | Allo ’Allo | Croft/Lloyd | Jennifer Smith | |
| 165 | Apr 2012 | Pygmalion | George Bernard Shaw | Sheila Grew | |
| 166 | Jun 2012 | Little Shop of Horrors | Ashman/Menken | Mike Penn | |
| 66. 2012-13 | 167 | Oct 2012 | Calendar Girls | Tim Firth | Alan Lowe |
| 168 | Feb 2013 | Life And Beth | Alan Ayckbourn | Chris Gardner | |
| 169 | Apr 2013 | Harvey | Mary Chase | Anne Chamberlain | |
| 170 | Jun 2013 | The Glass Menagerie | Tennessee Williams | Stephen Ralph | |
| 67. 2013-14 | 171 | Oct 2013 | Ghost Writer | David Tristram | Vida Green |
| 172 | Feb 2014 | Stepping Out | Richard Harris | ||
| 173 | Apr 2014 | The Railway Children | Mike Kenny | Jennifer Smith | |
| 174 | Jun 2014 | Flare Path | Terence Rattigan | Dawn Vigurs | |
| 68. 2014-15 | 175 | Oct 2014 | Cash On Delivery | Michael Cooney | Dan Holyhead |
| 176 | Feb 2015 | Present From The Past | Richard Everett | Anne Chamberlain | |
| 177 | Apr 2015 | The Memory Of Water | Sheelagh Stephenson | Stephen Ralph | |
| 178 | Jun 2015 | Volunteers | Hilary Mackelden | ||
| 69. 2015-16 | 179 | Oct 2015 | Dracula | Deane & Balderstone | Dave Brown |
| 180 | Feb 2016 | Brief Encounter | Noel Coward Emma Rice | Rachel Holmes | |
| 181 | Apr 2016 | Caught In The Net | Ray Cooney | Michelle Jennings | |
| 182 | Jun 2016 | Veronica’s Room | Ira Levin | Dawn Vigurs | |
| 70. 2016-17 | 183 | Oct 2016 | Bunkered | Lynn Brittney | Les Garrett |
| 184 | Feb 2017 | Glorious | Peter Quilter | Dawn Vigurs | |
| 185 | Apr 2017 | A Streetcar Named Desire | Tennessee Williams | Stephen Ralph | |
| 186 | Jun 2017 | God Of Carnage | Yasmina Reza | Chas Burnell | |
| 71. 2018 (Blue Coat School) | 187 | Feb 2018 | The Ghost Train | Arnold Ridley | Rebecca Holmes |
| 188 | Apr 2018 | Make It Murder | Jack Last | Anne Chamberlain | |
| 72. 2018-19 | 189 | Oct 2018 | Cheshire Cats | Gail Young | Michelle Jennings |
| 190 | Feb 2019 | Farndale Ave…Macbeth | McGillivray/Zerlin | Jill Simkin | |
| 191 | Apr 2019 | Mort | Pratchett/Briggs | Sam Evans | |
| 192 | Jun 2019 | Deathtrap | Ira Levin | Dawn Vigurs | |
| 73. 2019-20 *Covid | 193 | Oct 2019 | Parfumerie | EP Dowdall | Rachel Holmes |
| 194 | Feb 2020 | Towards Zero | Christie/Verner | Rebecca Holmes | |
| 74. 2022 | 195 | Feb 2022 | Nobody’s Perfect | Simon Williams | Nicola Dolphin- Brown |
| 196 | April 2022 | Quartermaine’s Terms | Simon Gray | Rod Bissett | |
| 197 | Jun 2022 | Dead Certain | Marcus Lloyd | Sara Peltonen | |
| 75. 2022-23 | 198 | Oct 2022 | Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde | David Edgar | Rebecca Holmes-Mears |
| 199 | Feb 2023 | Last Tango in Little Grimley and Joining the Club | David Tristram | Dave Brown | |
| 200 | Apr 2023 | Spider’s Web | Agatha Christie | Rachel Holmes | |
| 201 | Jun 2023 | Dad’s Army | Jimmy Perry & David Croft | Sam Evans | |
| 202 | Aug 2023 | Confessions of a Comedy Writer (Including two sketches ‘Peas’ and ‘Coffee’ | David Tristram | ||
| 76. 2023-24 | 203 | Oct 2023 | Dial ‘M’ For Murder | Frederick Knott | Rebecca Holmes – Mears |
| 204 | Feb 2024 | Leading Ladies | Ken Ludwig | Rachel Holmes | |
| 205 | Apr 2024 | Sheila’s Island | Tim Firth | Dominic Holmes | |
| 206 | June 2024 | Trap For a Lonely Man | Robert Thomas | Dawn Vigurs | |
| 77. 2024-25 | 207 | Oct 2024 | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | C.G. Bond | Rachel Holmes |
| 208 | Feb 2025 | Things I Know To Be True | Andrew Bovell | Sam Evans | |
| 209 | Apr 2025 | The Good Life | Adapted by Jeremy Sams Based on the TV Series by John Esmonde & Bob Larbey | Kerry Jones | |
| 210 | June 2025 | Absent Friends | Alan Ayckbourn | Dominic Holmes | |
| 78. 2025-26 | 211 | Oct 2025 | Spirit Level | Pam Valentine | Dawn Vigurs |
| 212 | Feb 2026 | How To Be Happy | David Lewis | ||
| 213 | April 2026 | Lucky Me | Robert Caisley | Dominic Holmes | |
| 214 | June 2026 | Quiz | James Graham | Rebecca Holmes – Mears |
The Fellowship Players 